Efficient Method of Transporting Coconut ( Cocos nucifera L.) Zygotic Embryos for Cryopreservation of Plumules by Encapsulation/Dehydration

Coconut is both socially and economically important crop in tropical and subtropical countries, thus the conservation of existing diversity of its germplasm is vital to maintain biodiversity, sustain crop production and utilisation of germplasm for crop improvement strategies. The recalcitrant storage behavior and large size of the coconut seed make it impossible to use as a germplasm storage material. Cryopreservation is an ideal means of long-term storage of germplasm which offers long-term storage capability with minimal storage space and maintenance requirements. The coconut embryo has been now adapted by various researchers for the purpose of germplasm exchange and it is now being routinely applied in germplasm collection and exchange activities with sufficient germination rates. The aim of the present study was to determine the effect of different coconut embryo transport/ storage methods [as solid endosperm plugs under cold temperature, embryos cultured in Solidified Agar Medium (SAM) or KCl solution under room temperature] on cryopreservation of plumules using encapsulation/dehydration method. The results revealed that plumules excised from embryos transported/ stored in SAM and pretreated with 1.0M sucrose could be cryopreserved with 71.8% survival and 56% recovery rates. The survival and recovery could be further increased up to 77.5% and 65% respectively by supplementation of 1.0M sucrose with 20 µM ABA.


Introduction
Coconut is both socially and economically important crop in tropical and subtropical countries, thus the conservation of existing diversity of its germplasm is vital to maintain biodiversity, sustain crop production and utilisation of germplasm for crop improvement strategies.The recalcitrant storage behavior and large size (Chin and Pritchard, 1988) of the coconut seed make it impossible to use as a germplasm storage material. Traditionally, coconut genetic resources are preserved as whole plants in field gene banks. These field gene banks in different countries are comprised of a total of 1416 coconut accessions (Batugal, 2005). However, conservation in the field gene banks is subjected to risks of losses caused by biological and climatic hazards. The most recent example is the threat of the deadly disease Bogia Coconut Syndrome on the survival of the international collection of the South Pacific's coconut accessions, held at a field gene bank in Papua New Guinea (http://www.nature.com/ news/south-pacific-coconut-gene-bank-underthreat-1.11792). In addition, field gene banks require huge land areas and routine maintenance is very expensive. Cryopreservation is an ideal means of long-term storage of germplasm which offers long-term storage capability with minimal storage space and maintenance requirements. This method enables maximum stability of phenotypic and genotypic characteristics of stored germplasm (Engelmann, 1997). It also provides the option for long-term backup of germplasm collections that might be at risk. Bajaj in 1984 reported the earliest attempt on the cryopreservation of coconut using whole zygotic embryo. Germination of a single embryo after freezing was reported by using DMSO and slow freezing in a classical protocol (Chin et al., 1989). Successful cryopreservation of coconut embryos from immature nuts (7-8 months after pollination) and mature nuts has been reported (Assy-Bah and Engelmann, 1992a, b). Inadequate recovery conditions led to the low recovery of plantlets in spite of high survival rates obtained after cryopreservation. Coconut plumule (embryo meristem and first leaves), which is known to be free of viral diseases, appears to be an interesting starting material for cryopreservation (Malaurie et al., 2002) and has been conserved using encapsulation/dehydration method.
Encapsulation-dehydration, a vitrification-based cryopreservation procedure is gaining importance and has greater potential for broad applicability. In this method, cell water is removed through osmotic and evaporative dehydration that increases cell viscosity to a critical point at which water forms a meta-stable glass on exposure to ultralow temperatures. Pretreatment with sucrose (0.5-1.5 M) and drying on silica gel are the most common ways of achieving osmotic and evaporative dehydration respectively (Padro et al., 2012;Sharaf et a.,l 2012). N'Nan et al., (2008) and Malaurie et al., (2002) have assessed the effect of different sucrose concentrations and dehydratyion regimes for coconut and achieved 40-70% survival after cryopreservation by encapsulation/ dehydration method. Apart from the embryo, pollen which is the other allowed material for coconut germplasm exchange has been checked for its viability at low and ultra low temperatures (Karun et al., 2006;Karun and Sajini, 2010).
Characteristics of coconut seed (bulky, heavy and recalcitrant) limited the collection of germplasm from some of the geographic areas. These limitations however had serious impact on genetic resource conservation as large amount of coconut genetic diversity is located in remote areas. International exchange of coconut germplasm has specific recommendations (Frison et al., 1993), where it has been established that movement of germplasm should be done only on the form of embryo culture or pollen (Diekmann, 1999;Hocher et al., 2004;Malaurie, 2001). The coconut embryo has been now adapted by various researchers for the purpose of germplasm exchange and it is now being routinely applied in germplasm collection and exchange activities (Engelmann, et al 2002). Even though this technique works well for some varieties, adjustments need to be done for certain varieties for large scale germplasm exchange activities. The simplest procedure of collecting embryos consists of collecting endosperm plugs together with the embryo and transport under aseptic cold conditions (Rillo and Paloma 1991). Other protocols (Assy-Bah et al., 1987;Karun, 2001) involve disinfection of embryos and in vitro inoculation of embryos in a growth medium. Method of transportation/ storage affects embryo quality which in turn plays a crucial role in success of cryopreservation. This is particularly important when considering international exchange of coconut germplasm for the establishment of multi-site International Coconut Genebanks (Batugal and Jayashree 2005).
Thus, the aim of the present study was to determine the effect of different coconut germplasm transport/storage methods on cryopreservation of plumules using encapsulation/dehydration method.

Plant material
Mature nuts were obtained from 12 month old nuts of the variety Sri Lanka Tall. The nuts were collected from palms at Bandirippuwa Estate, Coconut Research Institute of Sri Lanka.

Preparation of embryos for transportation/ storage
Three different transport/store conditions were tested. In the first method solid endosperm plugs were extracted using a cock borer as described by Rillo and Paloma (1991), washed in tap water and in 95% ethanol quickly to remove the fats, and then disinfected with 100% commercial bleach (5.25% active chlorine) for 20minutes. The plugs are then washed three times with sterile water and packed in sterile polypropylene bags and refrigerated for 10 days (Figure 1a). In the second and third methods, dissected coconut embryos were disinfected with 20% commercial bleach for 5 minutes, rinsed with sterile water for three times, cultured in SAM [ 0.45% (w/v), Sigma] and KCl solution (16.2 g/L) respectively (Figure 1b and c respectively) and then stored at 27ºC in the dark for 10 days. After the storage period, the endosperm plugs were re-sterilized in 100% commercial bleach for 20 minutes and embryos were dissected inside a laminar air flow cabinet ( Figure 1d). The embryos dissected from endosperm plugs and the embryos stored in SAM and KCl ( Figure 2e) were then disinfected with 20% commercial bleach for 5 minutes and washed with sterile water for 5 times before dissecting plumules. Plumules were dissected as described by Chan et al., (1998)

Encapsulation / dehydration and cryopreservation
Dissected plumules were precultured on solid Eeuwens Y3 growth medium (Eeuwens, 1976) for 4-7 days in order to screen the contaminated explants. The plumules were encapsulated in alginate beads composed of 3% (w/v) low viscosity alginic acid (Sigma Chemical Co. USA) in calcium free liquid Y3 medium (pH 5.8) and allowed to polymerize for 45 min in liquid Y3 medium with 100 mM CaCl2 and 0.15 M sucrose. Beads were then blotted dry on sterile filter papers to remove surface moisture. Encapsulated plumules were then subjected to pretreatment in cryoprotective medium (sucrose/ sucrose+ABA). Groups of 20 beads were put in each 125 mL Erlenmeyer flask containing 30 mL cryoprotective medium and shaken on a rotary shaker set at 90 to 100 rpm, at 27 ± 1ºC in the dark for 3 days. The beads were rapidly surface dried by blotting with sterile filter papers. Dehydration of beads (batches of 20) was carried out for 16 h inside glass jars by placing on top of 40 g dried silica gel separated by a filter paper. Half of the dehydrated beads were transferred to 2 mL cryotubes and directly plunged in to liquid nitrogen at least for 2 h. The other half of the beads was cultured in the solid Y3 recovery medium.

Pretreatment in sucrose
Two sucrose concentrations were tested for the pretreatment step for each of the embryo transport/storage conditions. Encapsulated plumules which were dissected from the embryos (Sri Lanka Tall variety) stored under three conditions were pretreated in the standard Y3 medium (Eeuwens 1976) supplemented with either 0.75 M or 1.0 M sucrose.

Pretreatment in ABA
Incorporation of abscisic acid in to the pretreatment medium was tested for two transport conditions. Plumules were dissected from embryos stored in SAM or in KCl solution. Encapsulated plumules were pretreated in the liquid Eeuwens Y3 medium, enriched with 1.0 M sucrose alone or in combination with three ABA concentrations (10, 20 and 40 µM).

In vitro culture and assessment of survival and recovery
Alginate beads containing plumules of control treatments (pretreated with cryoprotectant only or pretreated and dehydrated in silica gel and not cryopreserved) were directly cultured in 24 x 150 mm test tubes containing 20 mL Eeuwens medium (Eeuwens, 1976) with modifications (Sandoval et al., 2003) whereas cryopreserved beads were cultured after thawing inside a 40ºC water bath for 3 min. The medium was supplemented with 0.12 M sucrose and the pH was adjusted to 5.0 before adding charcoal.
The medium was solidified with 4 g/L Gelrite. Cultures were kept in the dark at 27 ±1°C until first few leaves emerged and then maintained in 12 h light.
The survival was assessed as the percentage of plumules manifesting new tissue growth (indicated by any sign of growth such as swelling, development of new leaf primordia and/or callus formation). Here, survival was chosen as a more sensitive indicator in the protocols tested in addition to the recovery of plumules and assessed after 2 months of in vitro culture. The recovery of plumules (indicated by the ability of plumules to grow in to plantlets) following desiccation alone or desiccation and freezing was assessed after 6 months in culture.

Statistical analysis
The experiments were arranged in a complete randomized design with two to three replicates of 10 plumules per treatment. Contaminated explants were eliminated before collecting data. Data was subjected to Analysis of Variance and Fisher's Lest-Significant test using GenStat 10.1 software.

Results
Combined effect of embryo transport/store conditions and sucrose pretreatment In this experiment, the effect of three different embryo transport/store conditions were tested on cryopreservation of coconut plumules. As sucrose has been reported to be an effective cryoprotectant for coconut plumules (N'Nan et al., 2008), studies were carried out using two different sucrose concentrations which have shown positive effects on coconut plumule cryopreservation.

Survival of plumules
Encapsulated plumules (without any of the treatments) did not show any difference in survival and re-growth in comparison with uncoated controls (data not shown). The survival of encapsulated plumules treated with cryopretectant but not dehydrated in silica gel, and not frozen plumules (which were not stored in liquid N2) was always over 95% for all transport methods (Table 1). There was no Encapsulated plumules pre-treated with sucrose, either in 0.75 M or 1.0 M showed very low survival rates ranging from 0 to 25.0 %, when they were cryopreserved directly without a dehydration step (Table 2). No significant difference (P = 0.524) in survival was observed in dehydrated and cryopreserved plumules transported by three methods tested. But higher survival percentages were recorded in the plumules transported as embryos cultured in SAM (71.8% in 1.0 M sucrose) and KCl (63.5% in 0.75 M sucrose). Sucrose concentration in the preculture medium did not affect significantly (P = 0.135) on plumule survival.

Recovery of plumules
Plumules which were non-dehydrated and non-cryopreserved showed high recovery rates (> 95%) irrespective of the transport/store condition and the sucrose concentration (table 3). However, dehydration caused a decrease in recovery of plumules which was significantly different among plumules excised from embryos transported/ stored in different ways (P < 0.001) ( Table 3). None of the dehydrated plumules recovered when the embryos were transported as endosperm plugs and pretreated with 0.75 M sucrose. The greatest recovery (80%) was obtained when non cryopreserved plumules were excised from embryos transported in SAM and pretreated with 1.0 M sucrose. Whereas, the recovery of unfrozen plumules of the two other transport conditions (plugs and KCl) ranged only between 22.2% and 27.8%, respectively (Table  3) Rapid freezing of plumules without dehydration resulted almost complete inhibition of plant recovery in all treatments (Table 4). There was a significant interaction effect (P = 0.019) of transport condition, sucrose concentration and dehydration. Although two sugar concentrations tested were able to protect a proportion of plumules from dehydration damage, only embryos which were transported in SAM and pretreated with 1.0 M sucrose showed significantly high recovery (56.8%) after cryo storage.

Effect of ABA in pretreatment medium
In an attempt to improve the percentage recovery, encapsulated plumules were precultured in 1.0 M liquid sucrose medium containing different ABA concentrations for three days prior to dehydration and freezing. Two transport/store conditions SAM and KCl were tested. The plumules transported/stored as embryos cultured on SAM medium showed higher survival rates (58.8% and 77.5% in 10% and 20% ABA respectively) after dehydration and cryopreservation compared to the plumules transported/stored as embryos in KCl (Table 5). Maximum survival rate of the plumules transported in KCl was recorded as 41.2% when they were pre-treated in either 20 or 40 µM ABA. In contrast, this is a remarkable increase of survival after cryopreservation when compared to the survival (12.5%; Table 2) obtained for plumules transported in KCl and pre-treated in 1.0 M sucrose devoid of ABA. A very low survival ranging from 0.0% to 18.8% was recorded after cryo storage (Table 5) of non dehydrated plumules in both transport conditions but none of them developed in to plantlets later on ( Table 6). Regardless of the ABA concentration embryo transport method had a significant effect on survival (P=0.01) and recovery of cryopreserved plumules. After freezing, the best regrowth of plumules was observed for plumules pretreated in 10 µM ABA (40.0%) and 20 µM ABA (65.0%) when embryos were stored in SAM (Table 6).

Recovery and plant regeneration
Surviving plumules resumed growth at variable pace but started after about four weeks at the earliest (Figure 2a). Leafy shoots mostly without roots were recovered after freezing (Figure 2b and d). Plumules that turned brown after cryopreservation did not recover in to  plantlets. Very rarely plumules exhibited survival by initiating callus like growth ( Figure  2c) with no further development. Root development of the surviving shoots in liquid Y3 medium was achieved by giving a IAA plus (200 µM) for two days (figure 2e). Majority of recovered plantlets were contaminated during sub-culturing and a very few plants were acclimatized in soil.

Discussion
The potential of exchanging and storing healthy germplasm is vital for the conservation and use of genetic resources for coconut breeding programmes. Coconut zygotic embryos are now routinely being transported between numerous laboratories to support germplasm collection and exchange activities. (Batugal and Engelmann 1998;Engelmann et al., 2002) However, even though coconut embryos are being transported in different conditions and they ensure high rates of embryo germination (N'Nan et al., 2012;Sisunandar et al., 2010) these germplasm exchange procedures have not been evaluated for the purpose of storage of coconut germplasm for long term conservation. In this study, coconut plumules originally transported/ stored in different conditions were successfully cryopreserved using encapsulation/ dehydration.
It has been demonstrated that successful cryopreservation is achieved by avoiding the formation of intra cellular ice crystals which are formed during the freezing process causing lethal physical damage to tissues (Gale et al., 2007). Encapsulation/dehydration is an effective, widely using vitrification method for freezing shoot apices of different plant species from both temperate and tropical origin (Gonzalez-Arno and Engelmann 2006) since it is a simple and inexpensive method providing high level of genetic stability (Sakai et al., 1990;Khoddamzadedh et al., 2011).
In the encapsulation/dehydration method, tissues are dehydrated by evaporative dehydration (Shibli et al., 2001) to minimize the intra cellular water content. The exposure of tissues directly to dehydration step causes harmful effects due to osmotic stress (Touchell et al., 2002). Normally, preculture in sugars (Sharaf et al., 2012); mainly sucrose or other cryoprotectants such as sugar alcohols (Ford et al., 2000), glycerol (Rajasekaran, 1996) and DMSO (Reed, 1990) is used to increase the tolerance of tissues to dehydration before the immersion in liquid nitrogen. Sucrose concentrations ranging from 0.75M -1.0M are suitable for ensuring high survival rates after cryopreservation for crops such as mulberry, apple, grapevine and citrus (Paul et al., 2000;Wang et al., 2000;Wang et al., 2002;Padro et al., 2012;). There are reports of using sucrose as a cryoprotectant for the cryopreservation of plumule explants of coconut (Hornang et al., 2001;N'Nan et al., 2008). N'Nan and others reported 39% survival and 16% recovery of coconut plumules after cryo storage when the encapsulated plumules were pretreated with 0.75M sucrose (N'Nan et al., 2008). On the other hand, when the plumules were pretreated with 1.0 M sucrose, the survival rate was approximately 34% and the recovery was 10%. It is noted that the embryos used for the above experiments have been transported as endosperm plugs only. In this study we obtained similar results for the survival of plumules transported as endosperm plugs when precultured in the two sucrose concentrations 0.75 M (42.6%) and 1.0 M (34.7%). However, the positive effect of transporting embryos in SAM was observed by obtaining considerably higher survival rate (71.8%) when cryoprotected in 1.0 M sucrose. This was further confirmed by obtaining more than 56% recovered plantlets after cryopreservation when the plumules were transported in SAM. The results obtained are interesting as it is shown that the medium surrounding the coconut embryo (endosperm or the supplemented medium) can be replaced by agar alone without nutrition factors which ensure higher survival and recovery rates. These findings will permit convenient exchange of coconut embryos between laboratories and allow efficient germplasm distribution among the coconut growing countries.
The role of ABA in desiccation and freezing tolerance has been demonstrated not only in higher plants but also in lower plants such as bryophytes (Senaratna et al., 1989;Werner et al., 1991). Pretreatment with ABA has been shown to be effective for cryopreservation of several moss species (Pence, 1998). There are reports of successful plant material cryopreservation by incorporating ABA to the pretreatment medium (Kendall et al., 1993;Na and Kondo, 1996;Fang et al., 2004;Uchendu et al., 2011). A combination of ABA and sucrose pretreatments improved the survival of cryopreserved coconut plumules (Bandupriya et al., 2007). Addition of ABA to the pretreatment medium increased the recovery of cryopreserved plumules by recording 38% (Malaurie et al., 2006) and 39% (Bandupriya et al., 2007) recovery when compared to the recovery rates (20%) obtained previously by N'Nan et al in 2008. However these experiments have been carried out by transporting embryos as endosperm plugs (Malaurie et al., 2006) or without applying any transport condition (Bandupriya et al., 2007). In this paper we describe significantly high (65%) recovery of cryopreserved plumules which were initially transported/stored in SAM and when they were pretreated in 1.0 M sucrose supplemented with 20 µM ABA. These findings show that ABA addition to the pretreatment medium improves the recovery after cryopreservation significantly. Moreover it is shown that the effect of ABA has been elevated by the use of SAM as a transport support medium for the exchange of coconut embryos and reveals the importance of the selection of a correct transport conditioning of embryos prior to cryopreservation. du procédé de cryoconservation de la plumule de cocotier. Les Actes du BRG 6: 449-468. Malaurie, B., Borges, M. and N'Nan, O. (2002) Research of an optimal cryopreservation process using encapsulation/ osmoprotection/ dehydration and encapsulation/osmoprotection /vitrification techniques on caulinary meristems of coconut (Cocos nucifera L.). Burotrop Bulletin 20:16.